Sampling and Analysis Protocol for Ontario Regulation 267/03 Made under the Nutrient Management Act, 2002 - Data Quality Requirements| Introduction
| Sampling Methods
| Laboratory Analysis
| 4.3 Analysis - Land Applied Materials4.3.1 Hydrogen Ion (pH)Matrix: Land Applied Materials (Non-agricultural source materials) AnalysisNon-agricultural source materials with pH less than 6.0 or pH greater than 8.5, should not be applied to crops when they are being grown. Method PrinciplepH is determined with a standard glass electrode pH meter. Sample PreparationSolid: Prepare aqueous slurry in the ratio of 1g sample: 9 mL water. Stir or shake for approximately 20 minutes, allow suspension to settle and then determine pH of liquid fraction. Liquid/Slurry: Decant, filter or centrifuge a portion of sample, then determine the pH of the liquid fraction. InstrumentationpH electrode and pH meter compensated to 25°C. Accuracy and reproducibility to 0.2 pH unit with a range of 0 - 14 and equipped with temperature compensation. Laboratory QC Samples per Run3 Buffer Checks, Sample Replicate and In-House Matrix Check. Method Performance CriteriaBias: ± 0.2 pH units Precision: ± 0.2 pH units Reference MethodMOE/LaSB - E3137 (solid) MOE/LaSB - E 3218 (liquid/slurry) Notes
4.3.2 Total Dry Matter/Total SolidsMatrix: Land Applied Materials AnalysisAccurate determination of the dry matter content of land-applied materials is necessary to calculate application rates on a moist basis. Method PrincipleA portion of sample is weighed as received, dried for 16 hours at 105 ± 5°C, cooled and reweighed. The percent total solid is determined. Sample PreparationDisaggregate the sample and pass through a 2 mm sieve. Take subsamples (10 - 25 g) of this mixture, and dry in an oven at 105 ± 5°C for 16 hours to a constant weight. Cool and reweigh sample to determine total solids as a percent of the fresh weight. InstrumentationBalance, capable of weighing ±0.01 g. Laboratory QC Samples per RunCalibration Check and Sample Replicate. Method - Performance CriteriaBias: 100 ± 10% Precision: ± 10% Reference MethodMOE/LaSB-3139 4.3.3 Total Organic Matter (Volatile Solids)Matrix: Solid or Liquid Land Applied Materials AnalysisMethod PrincipleA portion of ground sample is dried for 16 hours at 105°C ± 5°C, then muffled at 475°C ± 25°C for 4 hours. The weight loss, and per cent ash are determined. Sample PreparationDisaggregate the sample and pass through a 2 mm sieve, then take and grind a sub-sample to pass through a 0.355 mm sieve. Heat the sub-sample in a muffler oven at 475°C ± 25°C for 4 hours. Determine the weight loss, and per cent ash. InstrumentationMuffle furnace. Balance, capable of weighing ± 0.01 g. Laboratory QC Samples per RunCalibration Check and Sample Replicate. Method - Performance CriteriaAccuracy: 100 ± 10% Reference Method
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Analyte | RDL (μg/g) |
Acceptable Bias (%) |
Precision (Reproducibility) (% RDS) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cadmium | 2.0 | ± 20 | ± 20 |
| Chromium | 106 | ± 20 | ± 20 |
| Cobalt | 15 | N/A | N/A |
| Copper | 76 | ± 20 | ± 20 |
| Lead | 50 | ± 20 | ± 20 |
| Molybdenum | 2.5 | N/A | N/A |
| Nickel | 18 | ± 20 | ± 20 |
| Zinc | 185 | ± 20 | ± 20 |
* Bias is based upon the certified reference material, such as, WWS-26 from Environmental Resource Associate or EPA Quality Control Sample, municipal digested sludge (SPL # 2900).
MOE/LaSB - E3071 for liquid/slurry and solid; MOE/LSB - 3094 for Clear Liquid.
Matrix: Land Applied Materials (Non-agricultural source materials)
This analysis is required for non-agricultural source material only.
Mercury in the sample is converted to the inorganic form by acid digestion process. The inorganic mercury in aqueous solution is then reduced with stannous chloride, and analyzed by CV AAS.
Solid (e.g. dewatered sludge, filter cake - Method E3058)
Digest a portion of previously air dried ground and sieved sample with 50% v/v Aqua Regia (hydrochloric acid/Nitric acid - v/v 3:1) in the presence of potassium permanganate by heating within a temperature range of 90°C to 110°C for 1 hour and 15 minutes. Treat excess permanganate with hydroxylamine sulphate. Reduce inorganic mercury with stannous chloride prior to analysis. Adjust volume with pure deionized water, decant/filter and then analyze. Report results on dry weight basis.
Liquid/Slurry (e.g. liquid sludge, likely 1% to 10% solids - Method E3058)
Digest weighed aliquot of homogenized (well mixed) sample with 50% v/v Aqua Regia (hydrochloric acid/Nitric acid - v/v 3:1) in the presence of potassium permanganate by heating within a temperature range of 90°C to 110°C for 1 hour and 15 minutes. Treat excess permanganate with hydroxylamine sulphate. Reduce inorganic mercury with stannous chloride prior to analysis. Adjust volume with pure deionized water, decant/filter and then analyze. Report results on dry weight basis.
Clear Liquid (e.g. supernatant, less than 1% solids - Method E 3060)
Digest an aliquot of homogenized (well mixed) sample with concentrated sulphuric acid/nitric acid (1.2:0.5) in the presence of potassium persulphate and potassium dichromate for 2 hours at 87°C ± 3°C. Adjust volume with pure deionized water, decant/filter and then analyze.
Cold Vapour Flameless Atomic Absorption (CV-FAAS)
Method Blank, Matrix Matched In-House Control or CRM, Calibration Check and Sample Replicate.
| Analyte | RDL (μg/g) |
Acceptable Bias (%) |
Precision (Reproducibility) (% RDS) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mercury | 0.5 | ± 20 | ±20 |
* Bias is based upon the certified reference material, such as, CRM 145R (sewage sludge mixed origin) or BE - 1 (sewage sludge).
MOE/LaSB - E3060 (clear liquid), MOE/LaSB E3058 (slurry and solid)
Sample Preservation
Matrix: Land Applied Materials (Non-agricultural source materials)
This analysis is required for non-agricultural source material only.
A portion of sample is digested in oxidizing acid mixture to convert all forms of arsenic and selenium to arsenate (AsO4)3- and selenate (SeO4)2- respectively. The arsenate and selenate are then reduced with sodium borohydride to arsine and hydrogen selenide which are then analyzed by flameless AAS.
Solid - (e.g. dewatered sludge, filter cake - Method E3091)
Digest a portion of previously air dried ground and sieved sample with concentrated Nitric acid/Hydrochloric acid mixture (1:3) at 50 °C for 1 hour and then at 95 °C for an additional 3 hours. Adjust volume with pure deionized water, decant/filter and then analyze.
Liquid/Slurry (e.g. liquid sludge, likely 1% to 10% solids - Method E3091)
Digest a weighed aliquot of sample with concentrated Nitric acid/Hydrochloric acid mixture (1:3) at 50 °C for 1 hour and then at 95 °C for an additional 3 hours. Adjust volume with pure deionized water, decant/filter and then analyze. Report results on dry weight basis.
Clear Liquid (e.g. supernatant, less than 1% solids) (Method E 3302)
Digest an aliquot of liquid with concentrated Nitric acid/Hydrochloric acid mixture (1:3) at 50 °C for 1 hour and then at 95 °C for an additional 3 hours. Adjust volume with pure deionized water, decant/filter and then analyze.
Hydride - Flameless Atomic Absorption Spectrophotometry (HYD-FAAS)
Method Blank, Matrix Matched In-House Control or CRM, Calibration Check and Sample Replicate.
| Analyte | RDL (μg/g) |
Acceptable Bias (%) |
Precision (Reproducibility) (% RDS) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Arsenic | 7.5 | ± 20 | ± 20 |
| Selenium | 1.4 | ± 20 | ± 20 |
* Bias is based upon the certified reference material, such as, CRM 145R (sewage sludge mixed origin) or BE - 1 (sewage sludge).
MOE/LaSB - E3302 (clear liquid), MOE/LaSB E3091 (liquid/slurry and solid)
Matrix: Land Applied Materials
Total phosphorus and potassium content of land applied materials are determined to estimate the amount of plant available nutrients being applied to land. Sodium or boron content may need to be determined for land applied materials suspected of containing high concentrations of these elements, on a case by case basis.
A portion of sample is extracted with a heated, strong mixed acid solution, brought to volume with pure deionized water and analyzed using a spectrometric technique.
Solid: Digest a portion of previously dried and homogenized sample with concentrated Nitric acid/Hydrochloric acid mixture (1:3) by heating at 50°C for 1 hour and then at 95°C for another 3 hours. Adjust volume with pure deionized water, decant/filter and then analyze.
Liquid/slurry: Weigh an aliquot of homogenized (well mixed) sample and then digest with concentrated Nitric acid/Hydrochloric acid mixture (1:3) by heating at 50°C for 1 hour and then at 95°C for another 3 hours. Adjust volume with pure deionized water, decant/filter and then analyze.
ICP/AES
Method Blank, Matrix Matched In-House Control or CRM, Calibration Check and Sample Replicate.
Inter- and intra- lab precision must be within ±10% of the mean of samples from all accredited labs.
Under development
Matrix: Sewage Biosolids and other Non-Agricultural Source Materials (NASM)
Municipal sewage biosolids and any other material, other than untreated septage, that contains human body waste are required to be sampled and analyzed for E.coli. prior to land application
A volume of buffered dilution water is added to a weighed amount of biosolids and processed with a Stomacher or equivalent. Serial dilutions are then prepared using the supernatant. Serial dilutions are then plated out on mFC-BCIG agar (or other selective agar) and incubated for required time and the required temperature. Alternatively an equivalent estimate most probable number (MPN) statistical method can be used to quantify culturable organisms.
Add an amount of buffered dilution water to a weighed mass of biosolids material. Process in Stomacher or equivalent technology for 2 minutes. Decant off supernatant.
Classical microbiological techniques - selective agar, biochemicals for confirmation.
Positive and negative controls run with each set of samples, and addition of spiked samples for recovery.
Between analyst precision (method duplicate) and within analyst precision (analyst duplicate) and inter-technician comparative reading data points must be within 95% confidence limits (Standard Methods, 2005).
MOE/LaSB - E3433
Matrix: Sewage biosolids and any other material, other than untreated septage, that contains human body waste
NASM to be considered of CP1 pathogen quality are required to be sampled and analysed as per the regulation. Such material may not be utilized as a CP1 material where densities of viable salmonellae are at or above 3 most probable number (MPN) per 4-g sample (dry weight) or per 100-mL if aqueous NASM sample of < 1% total solids on a wet weight basis. A minimum of 100 mL or 4-g dry wt sample must be analyzed to report a non-detect.
The sample is diluted, homogenized and inoculated into selective growth media and all Salmonella spp. are enumerated statistically using the most probable number method (MPN), which involves making the required number of serial decimal dilutions of the original sample in three or five replicates to obtain a statistical estimate of salmonellae density. The specific method protocol must meet the performance criteria described below.
Liquid: A minimum of 100-mL or 4-gram sample volume must be accommodated by a modification of standard MPN procedures by increasing sample volumes or by concentration by filtration or other suitable mechanism.
Solid: A volume of buffered dilution water is added to a weighed amount of NASM and homogenized. Sterile. high-volume plastic bags can be used for homogenization, unless the sample contains hard debris that may pierce the plastic bag. Salmonella spp. are enumerated from the sample using the 3-tube MPN method of 3- replicates carried in 3 or more serial decimal dilutions. A minimum of 100 mL or 4-g sample must be analysed to report a non-detect.
Filter apparatus, incubators, sterile tubes, sterile, sealed, high capacity (e.g., 1-L) plastic bags (e.g., Stomacher bags or equivalent).
One method blank and one spiked positive control for every 20 samples, or each week during which samples are analyzed if 20 or fewer samples are analyzed.
Detection limits of Salmonella spp. in all matrices (biosolids and any other material, other than untreated septage, that contains human body waste.) are expected to be 3 MPN Salmonella MPN per gram dry weight of material based on validation work (Laboratory Methods Validation Study for Pathogens in Pulp and Paper Mill Biosolids and other NASM, Univ. of Guelph, Final Report for MOE, February 28, 2007).
And sample preparation for sludges:
Matrix: Sewage biosolids and any other material, other than untreated septage and Category B compost, that contains human body waste
Sewage biosolids and any other material, other than untreated septage, that contains human body waste may be tested to be considered of CP1 pathogen quality. This material cannot be deemed CP1 material if the level of total culturable enteroviruses exceeds 1 plaque forming units (pfu) per 4-g dry weight (wt). A minimum of 4-g sample on a dry wt basis must be analysed to report a non-detect. Category B compost is not required to be tested for total culturable enteroviruses to be considered CP1 pathogen quality.
Solids: Culturable enteroviruses are first adsorbed to solids under select solution conditions (such as pH) and concentrated by centrifugation followed by removal/desorption and solids removed by centrifugation by change in solution conditions.
Solids and liquids: Culturable enteroviruses in the centrate liquid after extraction from solids or viruses directly in the liquid NASM samples are concentrated by organic-flocculation and assayed by counting plaque forming units (pfu) on Buffalo Green Monkey (BGM) kidney cell cultures or equivalent cell-culture technology. This procedure may take approximately 16 days.
Solids: Samples are first conditioned using AlCl3 at pH 3.5 (or equivalent) to adsorb viruses to solids fraction and concentrated by centrifugation. Then viruses are desorbed from solids by physicochemical means and the aqueous fraction (containing the viruses) is clarified by centrifugation followed by serial or stacked membrane filtrations down to 0.2 µm. Total culturable viruses in the liquid fraction may be further concentrated by organic-flocculation and centrifugation if necessary.
pH meter, refrigerated centrifuge, stirrer/stir bars, membrane filtration apparatus, BGM (or equivalent) tissue cultures, tissue culture rocker apparatus and incubators with appropriate gas cylinders.
Sample bottles should not exceed 500 mL in size to permit rapid cooling of sample after collection. Samples should be shipped and stored frozen (-18°C) for up to 2 weeks prior to analysis. After processing, the virus eluate must be stored at 4±3°C and the viral assay must be completed within 24 hrs, or freeze at -70°C. Once thawed (rapidly at 37°C) keep at 4°C less than 24 hr until viral assay is complete.
One method blank and one spiked positive control for every 20 samples, or each week during which samples are analyzed if 20 or fewer samples are analyzed. Enteroviruses are required for positive controls, for example attenuated Poliovirus or Echovirus. At time of viral assay, at least 10% of the isolates should be confirmed by second passage on tissue cultures.
Under development. Detection limit expected is 1 virus particle 4-g (dry wt) sample based on work by U.S. EPA (Yanko 1987 Report No. EPA/600/1-87/014). Inter-laboratory precision testing resulted in a total standard deviation for all sludges and all labs for this method of 0.41 (as a log10 value).
ASTM (2004) Method D 4994-89. Standard practice for recovery of viruses from wastewater sludges. Procedure A. In: Annual Book of ASTM Standards- Section 11. Water and environmental technology. West Conshohocken, PA: American Soc. for Testing and Materials.
USEPA Report No. EPA/625/R-092/013. (Revised July 2003). Environmental Regulations and Technology: Control of pathogens and vector attraction in Sewage Sludge. Appendix H: Method for the recovery and assay of total culturble viruses from sludge. Cincinnati, OH:.
For liquid samples organic-flocculation procedure:
Matrix: Sewage biosolids and any other material, other than untreated septage and Category B compost, that contains human body waste
Sewage biosolids and any other material, other than untreated septage, that contains human body waste to be considered of CP1 pathogen reduction quality must be tested. Such material cannot be deemed a CP1 category material if the level of viable parasitic helminth ova exceeds 1 ovum per 4-g dry weight (wt). A minimum 4-g sample must be analysed in its entirety to report a non-detect. Category B compost is not required to be tested for viable helminth ova to be considered CP1 pathogen quality.
Ascaris ova are removed from material by washing, blending, screening and concentrated by settling followed by density gradient centrifugation. The fraction containing Helminth ova are collected, washed and concentrated by centrifugation, and then incubated 3-4 weeks in dilute H2SO4 (or equivalent) until control samples of Ascaris ova become embryonated (larval stages visible). Total and viable counts are determined by microscopic counting of total ova and those embryonated (viable) ova.
Samples are diluted in buffered solution followed by further processed by blending in buffered surfactant solution and coarse screening. After screened ova are settled out, they are concentrated by density gradient centrifugation using MgSO4 (or equivalent). The fraction containing ova is further screened and concentrated by centrifugation. The final samples are incubated 3-4 weeks at 26°C in dilute H2SO4 (or equivalent) until ova become embryonated.
Sample bottles should not exceed 500 mL in volume to permit rapid cooling of sample after collection. Samples should be immediately refrigerated and can be stored refrigerated for up to 1 month. Do not freeze as this may interfere with recovery efficiency due to changes in buoyant density.
One method blank and one spiked positive control for every 20 samples, or each week during which samples are analyzed if 20 or fewer samples are analyzed.
Detection limits are expected to be 1 viable ovum per 4- or 10-g dry wt sample mass based on work by U.S. EPA (Yanko 1987 Report No. EPA/600/1-87/014) and Gantzer et al. (2001 Wat Res 35(16):3763), respectively.
Matrix: Non-Agricultural Source Materials that are not sewage biosolids and do not contain human body waste
NASM that are not sewage biosolids and does not contain human body waste that wish to demonstrate CP1 pathogen reduction quality' are required to be sampled and analysed. Such material may not be applied to land where levels of Cryptosporidium are detected in a 4-g sample (dry wt) or a 100-mL aqueous sample. Detection limits are expected to be at or better than 25 oocysts per 4-g or 100mL sample. (Rose et al., 2004. Water Environment Research Foundation (WERF), Report No. 00-PUM-2T). A minimum of 100 mL for liquid NASM or 4-g dry wt sample solid sample must be analyzed to report a non-detect.
Cryptosporidium oocysts are concentrated from the sample, purified using immunomagnetic separation or equivalent technology and enumerated either by immunofluorescent and differential interference contrast (DIC) microscopy, quantitative PCR, or technology shown to produce equivalent results. The specific method protocol must meet the performance criteria described below. A method may be chosen to simultaneously detect Cryptosporidium and Giardia, provided all performance criteria are met.
Liquid: A volume of liquid is concentrated by centrifugation or other suitable mechanism.
Solid: A volume of buffered dilution water is added to a weighed amount of NASM.
Cryptosporidium oocysts are purified using immunomagnetic separation or equivalent technology. Cryptosporidium oocysts are enumerated either by immunofluorescent and differential interference contrast (DIC) microscopy, quantitative PCR, or technology shown to produce equivalent results.
Centrifuges, immunomagnetic separation apparatus, real-time (quantitative) PCR thermocycler and software, or appropriate microscope
One method blank and one spiked positive control for every 20 samples, or each week during which samples are analyzed if 20 or fewer samples are analyzed.
As per US EPA Methods 1622 and 1623
Method acceptance criteria are shown in Table 1. The initial and ongoing precision and recovery criteria are based on the results of spiked samples. Analysis of a minimum of 4 samples spiked with 100 to 500 oocysts is required to calculate the initial precision and recovery.
The acceptance criteria for mean recovery is 13 to 143% based on the following equation:
R= 100 x [(Nsp - Ns) ÷ T]
Where:
R is the percent recovery
Nsp is the number of oocysts detected in the spiked sample
Ns is the number of oocysts detected in the unspiked sample
T is the true value of the oocysts spiked
The maximum relative standard deviation of at least 5 samples with recovery between 24 and 100 % must be no greater than 55.
The maximum relative percent difference (precision) is 67. This is calculated according to the following equation:
RPD = 100 x [(|NMS – NMSD|) ÷ Xmean]
Where:
RPD is the relative percent difference
NMS is the number of oocysts detected in the matrix spike
NMSD is the number of oocysts detected in the matrix spike duplicate
Xmean is the mean number of oocysts detected in the matrix spike and duplicate
| Performance Test | Acceptance Criteria |
|---|---|
| Initial Precision and Recovery | |
| Mean recovery (percent) | 24-100 |
| Precision (as maximum relative standard deviation) | 55 |
| Ongoing precision and recovery (percent) | 11-100 |
| Matrix spike/matrix spike duplicate (for method modifications) | |
| Mean recovery1 (as percent) | 13-143 |
| Precision (as maximum relative percent difference) | 67 |
The acceptance criteria for mean MS/MSD recovery serves as the acceptance criteria for MS recovery during routine use of the method
Some sample matrices may prevent the acceptance criteria from being met
US EPA Method 1622 or 1623 for water may be modified for use in NASM matrices. MOE Method E3463 for abattoir waste water may be used. In any case, the method performance criteria must be met for initial precision and recovery.
Matrix: Non-Agricultural Source Materials that are not sewage biosolids and do not contain human body waste
NASM that are not sewage biosolids and do not contain human body waste, that wish to demonstrate CP1 pathogen reduction quality, are required to be sampled and analysed. Such material may not be applied to land where levels of Giardia are detected in a 4-g sample (dry wt) or a 100-mL aqueous sample. Detection limits are expected to be at or better than 25 cysts per 4-g or 100mL sample. (Rose et al. 2004. WERF Report No. 00-PUM-2T). A minimum of 100 mL for liquid NASM or 4-g dry wt solid sample must be analyzed to report a non-detect.
Giardia cysts are concentrated from the sample, purified using immunomagnetic separation or equivalent technology and enumerated either by immunofluorescent and differential interference contrast (DIC) microscopy, quantitative PCR, or technology shown to produce equivalent results. The specific method protocol must meet the performance criteria described below.
Liquid: A volume of liquid is concentrated by centrifugation or other suitable mechanism.
Solid: A volume of buffered dilution water is added to a weighed amount of NASM. Giardia cysts are purified using immunomagnetic separation or equivalent technology. Giardia cysts are enumerated either by immunofluorescent and differential interference contrast (DIC) microscopy, quantitative PCR, or technology shown to produce equivalent results.
Centrifuges, immunomagnetic separation apparatus, real-time (quantitative) PCR thermocycler and software, or appropriate microscope
One method blank and one spiked positive control for every 20 samples, or each week during which samples are analyzed if 20 or fewer samples are analyzed.
As per US EPA Methods 1622 and 1623
Method acceptance criteria are shown in Table 1. The initial and ongoing precision and recovery criteria are based on the results of spiked samples. Analysis of a minimum of 4 samples spiked with 100 to 500 cysts are required to calculate the initial precision and recovery.
The acceptance criteria for mean recovery is 13 to 143% based on the following equation:
R= 100 x [(Nsp - Ns) ÷ T]
Where:
R is the percent recovery
Nsp is the number of cysts detected in the spiked sample
Ns is the number of cysts detected in the unspiked sample
T is the true value of the cysts spiked
The maximum relative standard deviation of at least 5 samples with recovery between 24 and 100 % must be no greater than 55.
The maximum relative percent difference (precision) is 67. This is calculated according to the following equation:
RPD = 100 x [(|NMS NMSD|) ÷ Xmean]
Where:
RPD is the relative percent difference
NMS is the number of cysts detected in the matrix spike
NMSD is the number of cysts detected in the matrix spike duplicate
Xmean is the mean number of cysts detected in the matrix spike and duplicate
| Performance Test | Acceptance Criteria |
|---|---|
| Initial Precision and Recovery | |
| Mean recovery (percent) | 24-100 |
| Precision (as maximum relative standard deviation) | 49 |
| Ongoing precision and recovery (percent) | 14-100 |
| Matrix spike/matrix spike duplicate (for method modifications) | |
| Mean recovery1 (as percent) | 15-118 |
| Precision (as maximum relative percent difference) | 30 |
The acceptance criteria for mean MS/MSD recovery serves as the acceptance criteria for MS recovery during routine use of the method
Some sample matrices may prevent the acceptance criteria from being met
US EPA Method 1622 or 1623 for water may be modified for use in NASM matrices. MOE Method E3463 for abattoir waste water may be used. In any case, the method performance criteria must be met for initial precision and recovery.
| Introduction
| Sampling Methods
| Laboratory Analysis
|
| Data Quality
Requirements - Part One | Data
Quality Requirements - Part Two |
| Acronyms
| Glossary
|
| Author: | OMAFRA Staff |
|---|---|
| Creation Date: | 18 September 2009 |
| Last Reviewed: | 12 April 2011 |