Tower
Silo Capacities
 |
| Agdex#: |
100/732 |
| Publication Date: |
02/88 |
| Order#: |
88-033 |
| Last Reviewed: |
09/96 |
| History: |
Replaces Factsheet #82-076,
"Tower Silo" |
| Written by: |
J.C. Jofriet - School of Engineering/University
of Guelph; T.B. Daynard - Crop Science/University of Guelph
|
Table of Contents
- Introduction
- Concrete Silo Capacities for Forages
- Steel Silo Capacities for Forages
- Concrete Silo Capacities for High Moisture Corn
Introduction
The capacity of a tower silo depends on: (a) the compressibility of
the stored material; (b) the total volume of the silo; (c) the friction
between the wall of the silo and the material; and (d) the ratio of
the settled depth of silage to the diameter of the silo. This Factsheet
contains estimates of tower silo capacities for alfalfa silage, whole-plant
corn silage and various types of high moisture corn based on a series
of analyses of silo capacity carried out at the University of Guelph
and on research done at research establishments in the Netherlands and
Sweden. Values shown are more accurate than those available in previous
extension publications. Most previously published capacity tables overestimate
capacities for corn silage and underestimate those for high moisture
corn.
Tables 1 and 2 show the capacities, in tonnes, of most common silo
sizes for alfalfa and whole-plant corn silage. The capacities in Table
1 were obtained using a friction coefficient of 0.6, a reasonable
estimate for as-cast concrete walls. Table 2 capacities were
calculated using a friction coefficient of 0.4; this coefficient has
been found appropriate for glass-lined steel walls. Concrete silos coated
inside with a hard glass-like coating will probably have capacities
approximating those in Table 2. Badly corroded rough concrete
walls, on the other hand, may well reduce the capacity below that shown
in Table 1.
Table 1. Estimated concrete silo capacities
for forages, in tonnes (a)
| Silo Diameter x Settled
Depth |
Alfalfa
Silage |
Corn
Silage |
|
| (m)
|
(ft) |
40% |
50%(b) |
60% |
70% |
55%
|
60% |
65% |
70% |
| 3.7 x 9.1 |
12 x 30 |
32 |
40 |
52 |
75 |
43 |
49 |
56 |
67 |
12 x 30 |
| 3.7 x 12.2 |
12 x 40 |
45 |
56 |
73 |
105 |
60 |
68 |
79 |
93 |
12 x 40 |
| 3.7 x 15.2 |
12 x 50 |
57 |
71 |
94 |
136 |
77 |
88 |
101 |
120 |
12 x 50 |
| 4.3 x 12.2 |
14 x 40 |
63 |
78 |
103 |
148 |
84 |
96 |
110 |
130 |
14 x 40 |
| 4.3 x 15.2 |
14 x 50 |
81 |
101 |
134 |
193 |
110 |
124 |
143 |
168 |
14 x 50 |
| 4.3 x 16.8 |
14 x 55 |
90 |
113 |
149 |
215 |
122 |
139 |
159 |
187 |
14 x 55 |
| 4.9 x 15.2 |
16 x 50 |
109 |
137 |
181 |
261 |
148 |
167 |
191 |
224 |
16 x 50 |
| 4.9 x 18.3 |
16 x 60 |
135 |
169 |
224 |
323 |
182 |
206 |
235 |
275 |
16 x 60 |
| 4.9 x 19.8 |
16 x 65 |
147 |
185 |
245 |
354 |
200 |
225 |
258 |
300 |
16 x 65 |
| 5.5 x 15.2 |
18 x 50 |
142 |
178 |
236 |
339 |
191 |
216 |
247 |
288 |
18 x 50 |
| 5.5 x 18.3 |
18 x 60 |
176 |
221 |
293 |
421 |
237 |
266 |
304 |
353 |
18 x 60 |
| 5.5 x 21.3 |
18 x 70 |
211 |
264 |
351 |
504 |
283 |
317 |
361 |
419 |
18 x 70 |
| 6.1 x 18.3 |
20 x 60 |
224 |
281 |
372 |
533 |
298 |
335 |
381 |
442 |
20 x 60 |
| 6.1 x 21.3 |
20 x 70 |
268 |
337 |
446 |
639 |
357 |
399 |
453 |
524 |
20 x 70 |
| 6.1 x 24.4 |
20 x 80 |
314 |
394 |
522 |
746 |
415 |
464 |
526 |
607 |
20 x 80 |
| 7.3 x 18.3 |
24 x 60 |
338 |
423 |
559 |
796 |
442 |
494 |
560 |
647 |
24 x 60 |
| 7.3 x 21.3 |
24 x 70 |
407 |
511 |
674 |
956 |
529 |
590 |
667 |
767 |
24 x 70 |
| 7.3 x 24.4 |
24 x 80 |
479 |
600 |
790 |
1118 |
616 |
685 |
773 |
888 |
24 x 80 |
| 7.3 x 27.4 |
24 x 90 |
551 |
690 |
908 |
1281 |
704 |
782 |
880 |
1009 |
24 x 90 |
| 9.1 x 24.4 |
30 x 80 |
796 |
993 |
1297 |
1813 |
989 |
1164 |
1343 |
1480 |
30 x 80 |
| 9.1 x 27.4 |
30 x 90 |
920 |
1146 |
1494 |
2079 |
1129 |
1341 |
1547 |
1706 |
30 x 90 |
| 9.1 x 30.5 |
30 x 100 |
1046 |
1301 |
1692 |
2346 |
1270 |
1520 |
1754 |
1934 |
30 x 100 |
| 9.1 x 33.5 |
30 x 110 |
1173 |
1457 |
1891 |
2614 |
1411 |
1701 |
1962 |
2165 |
30 x 110 |
(a) 1 tonne 1000kg: the capacity in tons (2000 lb) can be obtained
by multiplying the capacities in the table by 1.1
(b) moisture content in percent (wet basis)
Table 2. Estimated steel silo capacities
for forages, in tonnes (a)
| Silo Diameter x
Settled Depth |
Alfalfa
Silage |
Corn
Silage |
|
| (m)
|
(ft) |
40% |
50%(b) |
60% |
70% |
55%
|
60% |
65% |
70% |
| 3.7 x 9.1 |
12 x 30 |
34 |
43 |
56 |
81 |
46 |
52 |
60 |
70 |
12 x 30 |
| 3.7 x 12.1 |
12 x 40 |
49 |
61 |
80 |
115 |
65 |
74 |
84 |
99 |
12 x 40 |
| 3.7 x 15.2 |
12 x 50 |
63 |
79 |
105 |
151 |
85 |
96 |
110 |
128 |
12 x 50 |
| 4.3 x 12.2 |
14 x 40 |
68 |
85 |
112 |
161 |
91 |
102 |
117 |
137 |
14 x 40 |
| 4.3 x 15.2 |
14 x 50 |
89 |
112 |
148 |
212 |
119 |
134 |
152 |
177 |
14 x 50 |
| 4.3 x 16.8 |
14 x 55 |
100 |
125 |
166 |
238 |
133 |
149 |
170 |
197 |
14 x 55 |
| 4.9 x 15.2 |
16 x 50 |
120 |
150 |
198 |
283 |
158 |
177 |
202 |
234 |
16 x 50 |
| 4.9 x 18.3 |
16 x 60 |
150 |
188 |
248 |
354 |
196 |
220 |
249 |
287 |
16 x 60 |
| 4.9 x 19.8 |
16 x 65 |
166 |
207 |
274 |
389 |
216 |
241 |
273 |
314 |
16 x 65 |
| 5.5 x 15.2 |
18 x 50 |
155 |
195 |
256 |
365 |
203 |
227 |
258 |
299 |
18 x 50 |
| 5.5 x 18.3 |
18 x 60 |
176 |
221 |
293 |
421 |
252 |
281 |
318 |
367 |
18 x 60 |
| 5.5 x 21.3 |
18 x 70 |
211 |
264 |
651 |
504 |
302 |
336 |
379 |
435 |
18 x 70 |
| 6.1 x 18.3 |
20 x 60 |
247 |
308 |
405 |
572 |
315 |
351 |
396 |
456 |
20 x 60 |
| 6.1 x 21.3 |
20 x 70 |
300 |
374 |
490 |
688 |
377 |
419 |
471 |
540 |
20 x 70 |
| 6.1 x 24.4 |
20 x 80 |
354 |
441 |
576 |
806 |
439 |
487 |
547 |
625 |
20 x 80 |
| 7.3 x 18.3 |
24 x 60 |
368 |
459 |
600 |
842 |
461 |
512 |
577 |
662 |
24 x 60 |
| 7.3 x 21.3 |
24 x 70 |
449 |
558 |
727 |
1013 |
551 |
611 |
686 |
784 |
24 x 70 |
| 7.3 x 24.4 |
24 x 80 |
432 |
660 |
857 |
1187 |
642 |
710 |
795 |
907 |
24 x 80 |
| 7.3 x 27.4 |
24 x 90 |
616 |
764 |
988 |
1361 |
734 |
809 |
905 |
1031 |
24 x 90 |
| 9.1 x 24.4 |
30 x 80 |
867 |
1070 |
1379 |
1892 |
1033 |
1269 |
1459 |
1606 |
30 x 80 |
| 9.1 x 27.4 |
30 x 90 |
1007 |
1240 |
1590 |
2169 |
1202 |
1472 |
1690 |
1860 |
30 x 90 |
| 9.1 x 30.5 |
30 x 100 |
1150 |
1411 |
1803 |
2447 |
1374 |
1678 |
1923 |
2116 |
30 x 100 |
| 9.1 x 33.5 |
30 x 110 |
1294 |
1584 |
2017 |
2726 |
1549 |
1886 |
2159 |
2374 |
30 x 110 |
(a) 1 tonne 1000kg: the capacity in tons (2000 lb) can
be obtained by multiplying the capacities in the table by 1.1
(b) moisture content in percent (wet basis)
No tests have been carried out at Guelph for grass. Based on work done
in the Netherlands grass consolidates somewhat more than alfalfa. Capacities
for grass silage may be estimated from Tables 1 and 2 by increasing
the alfalfa silage capacities by 10, 15 and 20% for moisture contents
of 50, 60 and 70% respectively.
Table 3 presents silo capacities for high moisture corn. Capacities
for whole shelled and ground shelled corn, as well as ground ear corn
are shown. The capacity figures in Table 3 were calculated on
the basis of a friction coefficient of 0.6 an appropriate estimate for
concrete. High moisture corn is far less compressible than forage and,
therefore, friction has a much less effect on capacity. It is recommended
that for very smooth wall surfaces, such as glass-lined steel or epoxy
coated concrete, that the capacities in Table 3 be increased by 3%.
Table 3. Estimated concrete silo capacities
for high moisture corn, in tonnes (a)
| Silo Diameter |
Settled
Depth |
Whole
shelled corn |
Ground
Shelled Corn |
Ground
Ear Corn |
|
| (m)
|
(ft) |
25% |
30%(b) |
35% |
25% |
30 |
35%
|
30% |
35% |
40% |
| 3.7 x 9.1 |
12 x 30 |
74 |
81 |
89 |
77 |
86 |
96 |
66 |
75 |
67 |
12 x 30 |
| 3.7 x 12.2 |
12 x 40 |
99 |
109 |
120 |
104 |
116 |
131 |
89 |
102 |
118 |
12 x 40 |
| 3.7 x 15.2 |
12 x 50 |
125 |
137 |
152 |
131 |
146 |
165 |
113 |
129 |
150 |
12 x 50 |
| 4.3 x 12.2 |
14 x 40 |
137 |
150 |
165 |
143 |
160 |
180 |
123 |
141 |
161 |
14 x 40 |
| 4.3 x 15.2 |
14 x 50 |
172 |
189 |
209 |
180 |
202 |
228 |
155 |
179 |
208 |
14 x 50 |
| 4.3 x 16.8 |
14 x 55 |
190 |
209 |
231 |
199 |
223 |
252 |
172 |
198 |
230 |
14 x 55 |
| 4.9 x 15.2 |
16 x 50 |
227 |
249 |
275 |
267 |
301 |
205 |
237 |
276 |
224 |
16 x 50 |
| 4.9 x 18.3 |
16 x 60 |
274 |
301 |
333 |
288 |
323 |
365 |
249 |
287 |
335 |
16 x 60 |
| 4.9 x 19.8 |
16 x 65 |
298 |
327 |
362 |
313 |
351 |
397 |
271 |
313 |
365 |
16 x 65 |
| 5.5 x 15.2 |
18 x 50 |
289 |
318 |
351 |
303 |
340 |
384 |
263 |
303 |
353 |
18 x 50 |
| 5.5 x 18.3 |
18 x 60 |
350 |
384 |
425 |
367 |
412 |
466 |
318 |
368 |
429 |
18 x 60 |
| 5.5 x 21.3 |
18 x 70 |
410 |
451 |
499 |
431 |
484 |
547 |
374 |
434 |
506 |
18 x 70 |
| 6.1 x 18.3 |
20 x 60 |
434 |
477 |
528 |
456 |
512 |
579 |
396 |
459 |
535 |
20 x 60 |
| 6.1 x 21.3 |
20 x 70 |
510 |
561 |
620 |
536 |
602 |
680 |
466 |
541 |
631 |
20 x 70 |
| 6.1 x 24.4 |
20 x 80 |
585 |
644 |
713 |
616 |
692 |
782 |
536 |
622 |
727 |
20 x 80 |
| 7.3 x 18.3 |
24 x 60 |
632 |
694 |
768 |
663 |
745 |
841 |
578 |
670 |
781 |
24 x 60 |
| 7.3 x 21.3 |
24 x 70 |
742 |
816 |
902 |
780 |
876 |
989 |
681 |
790 |
922 |
24 x 70 |
| 7.3 x 24.4 |
24 x 80 |
852 |
938 |
1037 |
896 |
1007 |
1132 |
784 |
910 |
1063 |
24 x 80 |
| 7.3 x 27.4 |
24 x 90 |
963 |
1059 |
1172 |
1012 |
1138 |
1285 |
887 |
1030 |
1204 |
24 x 90 |
| 9.1 x 24.4 |
30 x 80 |
1346 |
1480 |
1637 |
1413 |
1587 |
1791 |
1242 |
1442 |
1681 |
30 x 80 |
| 9.1 x 27.4 |
30 x 90 |
1521 |
1673 |
1851 |
1597 |
1794 |
2025 |
1405 |
1633 |
1905 |
30 x 90 |
| 9.1 x 30.5 |
30 x 100 |
1697 |
1867 |
2064 |
1781 |
2001 |
2258 |
1569 |
1824 |
2128 |
30 x 100 |
| 9.1 x 33.5 |
30 x 110 |
1872 |
2060 |
2278 |
1965 |
2208 |
2492 |
1734 |
2016 |
2352 |
30 x 110 |
(a) 1 tonne 1000kg: the capacity in tons (2000 lb) can
be obtained by multiplying the capacities in the table by 1.1
(b) moisture content in percent (wet basis)
The capacity tables are based on fully settled silage. The silo height
may be used if the silo is topped up one to two weeks after initial
filling. If this is not done the capacities in Tables 1, 2 and 3 should
be determined on the actual settled depth of silage after about two
to three weeks rather than the silo height. Silage may settle between
10 and 15% during the first two weeks after filling. Another adjustment
should be made if space in the top of silo allows the piling up of material
in a cone-shaped heap. To allow for this pile, one-third of the height
of the cone can be added to the settled depth of the silage measured
at the base of the cone.
There is no significant difference in capacity between topunloading
silos and those with sweep-arm bottom-unloading equipment. However,
the tables do not account for the large cavity formed with flail-type
bottom-unloading equipment and should not be used directly for silos
thus equipped.
| Top of Page |
University of Guelph For more information:
Toll Free: 1-877-424-1300
Local: (519) 826-4047
E-mail: ag.info.omafra@ontario.ca
|