In This Section |
Infosheet #17 Manure Use and Management
Table of Contents
IntroductionThis infosheet provides background to Worksheet #17 of the Environmental Farm Plan Workbook. It outlines options that you could adopt to address problem areas in your operation. In most cases you'll need more information before implementation. Please refer to the resource materials listed in the infosheet, and consult OMAFRA Environmental Farm Plan (EFP) Technical Advisors. All options are classed as Actions, Compensating Factors or Monitoring. Actions address the areas of concern identified, and will change the EFP rating to (3) or Best (4). Compensating Factors are alternatives that will adequately address the concerns, but will not change the rating in the EFP worksheets. Monitoring is an alternative only in special circumstances and is explained in the worksheet when and how it can be used. OMAFRA = Ontario Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs | Top of Page | Livestock Feed EfficiencyIssue: 17-1 Feed efficiency toolsInefficient use of feed nutrients not only adds to the cost of production, but increases the risk of environmental problems. Feed additives and medications are critical tools in ensuring animal health and efficiency that require good management. Feeding management strategies, equipment design and manure testing can also have an impact on feed efficiency. What can you do?Option #1 - ActionImplement at least two of the following:
For More Information:
| Top of Page | Issue: 17-2 Feed analysis, ration balancing and mixer calibrationLivestock diet must be considered in relation to manure production. Dietary strategies are one of the most cost-effective methods of reducing the nutrients in manure. Many dietary strategies are cost saving because the direct cost of nutrients is reduced, or feed efficiency and production are improved. Ration balancing results in meeting required nutrients in a most cost effective and nutrient efficient manner. Nutrients not utilized from feed for animal production are excreted in the manure. When animals are separated into age categories and/or stage of production and are fed according to needs, excessive nutrients are minimized in the manure. Feed inventory records and analyzed rations help in balancing of rations. Consistent feed quality is important in maintaining production. Regular mixer calibration helps ensure that required amount of feed is actually being fed. What can you do?Option #1 - ActionImplement at least three of the following:
Option #2- Compensating Factor
For More Information:
| Top of Page | Issue: 17-3 Nutrient Management PlanA nutrient management plan (NMP) is a living document that considers all nutrients on the farm with regard to crop needs and environmental impact. A detailed plan (with no "red flags") will help to achieve optimal crop yields and product quality, and protect soil and water resources. Without a nutrient management plan, farmers may unknowingly apply nutrients at excessive rates which could lead to contamination of surface and/or ground water, as well as an accumulation of nutrients in the soil. A nutrient management plan helps track nutrient use on the farm and will most often reduce commercial fertilizer needs. Red flags are indicators that a planned practice will lead to a higher risk of environmental contamination, while a yellow flag indicates a caution of either approaching higher environmental risk or an economic caution. Frequent manure applications in the past on many livestock farms have resulted in phosphorus soil test levels of greater than 30 mg/L (or 30 ppm). At this soil test level there is no additional crop requirement for phosphorus, and an increased risk of movement to surface water as soil test P increases. Phosphorus applied at a rate equal to crop uptake will not cause an increase in soil test phosphorus. A nutrient management plan also allows a person to examine management practices and their effect on nutrients or environmental limitations. It can also serve as a record keeping tool. What can you do?Option #1 - ActionComplete a nutrient management plan that includes:
Complete NMP as outlined above and:
Follow through with appropriate record keeping
Note: If a nutrient management plan has been completed (without red flags and with follow through of record keeping), then the Worksheet participant can move to question 8. For More Information:
| Top of Page | Issue: 17-4 Ratio of livestock to farm unit acreageNote: To calculate the nutrient units on the farm use the chart on pg 169-172. A concentrated amount of livestock in one area can present a problem of noise and odour. Concentrated livestock operations produce large amounts of manure; sometimes without the landbase to apply the manure based on fertilizer recommendations. The risk of odour complaints and/or soil and water contamination increases when large volumes of manure are stored on the farmstead and/or applied to a small land base. Many farms with completed nutrient management plans have about 1 NU/cropland acre. When farms have 2 NU/acre it results in the requirement for manure to be applied at high rates to legumes, or to a rotation that includes continuous corn. What can you do?Option #1 - ActionLower the ratio of livestock to farm acreage:
For More Information:
| Top of Page | Issue: 17-5Application rate and adjustment to amount of fertilizer used (organic and inorganic)Application rate: see application rate table (pg 173) in worksheet 17. Applying manure and organic wastes at high rates or on the same landbase every year can result in an oversupply of nutrients and increase risk of contaminated runoff. It is important not to apply more nitrogen than the crop can utilize, since the nitrogen (especially on sandy soils) has the potential to leach into and contaminate groundwater. Excess phosphorus can enter surface water and encourage excessive growth of aquatic vegetation. Ideally a farm will have enough landbase that manure does not have to be applied on every acre every year. This allows for improved crop rotation and for easier balancing of nutrients. Fertilizer adjustmentIt is important to realize that the nutrient content of applied manure or organic material counts towards fulfilling your crop nutrient requirements. If fertilizer application is not adjusted according to the nutrient content of applied manure, you will be oversupplying nutrients to your crop and increasing the crop input costs and breakeven price. What can you do?Option #1 - ActionApply manure at low or moderate rates to less than 50% of cropland and adjust fertilizer rates:
Apply manure on less than 50% of the crop land each year. This will make the best economic use of nutrients from manure/organic materials and will reduce the overall farm fertilizer bill while reducing the risk of increasing soil fertility to levels where risk to environment increases. Reduce amount of fertilizer used by the nutrient value of applied manure/organic materials e.g. crop nutrient requirements - (manure nutrients added + nutrient credits) = commercial fertilizer nutrient(s) required. For More Information:
| Top of Page | Issue: 17-6 Distance to surface waterThere are potential pollutants in manure that can contaminate surface water. They include ammonia, phosphate, bacteria, and organic matter. In order to reduce the risk to nearby surface water manure should be spread away from surface water and tile drain inlets. In addition, manure should be applied at appropriate rates based on crop need and less than liquid loading rates to prevent manure runoff. Liquid loading rates are determined by considering steepness of slope and soil texture. The steeper the slope and higher the clay content of the soil, the lower the rate that results in liquid movement. When manure is applied near surface water there should be a separation distance adjacent to the top of the bank, depending upon type of material, slope, soil characteristics and method of incorporation. A vegetated buffer strip adjacent to surface water will help to reduce the amount of soil and contaminants that may reach surface water. Areas of the field where concentrated flow moves toward surface water should also be avoided especially with spring applied manure when melting snow, wet soils and frequent rainfall increase the runoff and erosion that reaches surface water. What can you do?Option #1 - ActionKeep a minimum separation distance when spreading manure near surface water:
Option #2 - ActionMaintain a setback from surface water:
For More Information:
| Top of Page | Issue: 17-7 Nitrate movement to groundwaterNitrogen BasicsDuring the fall, winter and early spring, when crops are not growing, the risk of nitrates moving below the root zone is highest. The sources of nitrate include N left over after crop harvest (more applied than the crop used) and N from fall applied manure. Manure nitrogen is predominantly in the ammonium and organic form. The ammonium portion is converted to the nitrate form quickly during good growing conditions (i.e. late summer). Manure applied after cereal harvest, in late summer and early fall on sandy soils without growing crops (ie cover crops) provides the highest risk for nitrate movement to groundwater. Manure applied in the fall on clay loam and clay soils will have little risk of leaching below the root zone, however loss due to denitrification (N2 or N20) is higher. Nitrogen (N) is present in the soil and organic materials in three main forms: Ammonium-N, Nitrate-N and Organic-N Most Ammonium-N is converted to nitrate-N in the soil before being taken up by plants. Much of the nitrogen in manure is in the organic form. In this form it is not available to plants until it has been converted into ammonium-N. The rate at which this occurs depends on temperature, moisture and degradability of the organic material. What can you do?Option #1 - Action
Option #2 - Action
Option #3- Action
For More Information:
| Top of Page | Issue: 17-8Distance to wellsContamination to wells can occur in two different ways. If the well is poorly constructed and surface water (with contaminants) flows toward and enters the well or, if contaminants flow through and below the soil surface and enter the groundwater. The more shallow or poorly constructed the well, the higher the risk for contaminants to enter the groundwater. Wells that have been abandoned, without being properly sealed are a direct pathway to groundwater. If manure is spread directly over an unmarked abandoned well, the risk for contaminants to enter the groundwater is high. What can you do?Option #1 - Action
For More Information:
| Top of Page | Issue: 17-9 Manure testing and calibrationManure testing Different types of manure and other organic materials have very different nutrient values, and nutrient values can vary even within the same manure type. By testing the manure for specific nutrients, including nitrogen, you will have a better idea of the amount of nutrients that are being applied to the soil. This will allow you to calculate the amount of additional fertilizer, if any, that is required for the planned crop. Knowledge of nutrient value of manure (commercial fertilizer equivalent) will also help in obtaining manure agreements or in selling manure off-farm. Calibration It is also important to measure the amount and uniformity of manure that is applied by calibrating application equipment. This will help to avoid over-application or under application of nutrients. Uniform application will help ensure consistent nutrient levels across the field. What can you do?Option #1 - Action
| Top of Page | Issue: 17-10 Soil conditions when manure/organic materials are appliedIt is best to avoid spreading manure or organic materials on wet soil due to the increased risk of soil compaction. Compacted soils slow infiltration, increase runoff potential and affect overall soil health. Crops grown on compacted soils are often lower yielding and have higher potential for root diseases. Avoid surface applying manure or organic materials to steeply sloping fields, especially near surface water. The risk of contamination due to runoff increases as % slope increases. Avoid manure application if severe weather is expected, as this could lead to contaminated runoff reaching surface water. Where possible incorporate all manure before rainfall occurs. What can you do?Option #1 - ActionYour land should meet all of the following criteria before applying manure:
For More Information:
| Top of Page | Issue: 17-11 Timing of incorporationWith liquid manure, the largest portion (50% to over 75%) of the total nitrogen is in the ammonium form. This form is easily volatilized or lost to the air. When manure is not immediately incorporated, there is increased odour and risk for the ammonium portion of the nitrogen to escape into the air as a gas. This risk is highest when weather conditions are hot and dry. In these conditions surface applied liquid manure can lose up to 90% of the ammonium portion of the manure nitrogen within a few days of application. Where manure is applied to living crops or high residue fields, volatilization losses can be significant, but lower than when applied to bare soil. When manure is applied in weather conditions where soil/air temperatures are less than 10°C, microbial activity in the soil is reduced, which also reduces rate of volatilization. What can you do?Option #1 - ActionIncorporate manure after spreading:
Option #2 - Action
For More Information:
| Top of Page | Issue: 17-12 Knowledge of responsible application methodsIt is important for farm operators and custom manure applicators to attend educational courses on manure management. Preparing and following nutrient management plans reduces the risks associated with manure/organic material application. Increased knowledge of material nutrient content, soil and crop nutrient needs, and best management practices will ensure responsible application of manure. What can you do?Option #1 - ActionEducate yourself on best management practices:
Attend education courses:
Apply the skills learned to your operation For More Information:
| Top of Page | Issue: 17-13 Winter application of manureOccasionally the opportunity to apply manure during winter months with immediate incorporation occurs. However, manure application in winter should never be part of the plan, but rather only part of a contingency. When soils are frozen and/or snow covered and manure is surface applied, there is little opportunity for infiltration. Snowmelt conditions are often accompanied with rain events, which results in surface flow of contaminated water into surface water (rivers, streams) or concentrated nutrients in ponded areas. When winter application is part of a contingency plan due to inadequate storage, assess the risks of your land base to determine the area with least risk for surface water contamination. What can you do?Option #1 - Action
Option #2 - Action
For More Information:
| Top of Page | Issue: 17-14 Transportation and transfer of manure from storage to fieldIt is extremely important to take steps to prevent a manure leak or spill from occurring. Spills can flow into surface water or leach into ground water sources which could contaminate drinking water supplies as well as damage aquatic habitats. Manure spills can also contaminate the soil by concentrating a large amount of nutrients making crop growth difficult. When moving manure from storage to field, consider wear and tear (axle weights) on the roads. Manure should never cover road surfaces. What can you do?Option #1 - ActionReport all spills immediately to the Ministry of the Environment:
For More Information:
| Top of Page | Issue: 17-15 Operation of liquid manure direct flow systemA spill occurring when a pumping system is left unattended can potentially result in large volumes of manure contaminating soil and water. In order to prevent a spill, a direct flow system must have the capacity to be shutdown at a moment's notice. This can be accomplished by having two people with a radio link operating the system or by using a radio controlled shutdown system. What can you do?Option #1 - ActionBe able to shutdown the pumping system within 1 minute:
Option #2 - ActionBe able to shutdown the pumping system at the first sign of any problem:
Option #3 - ActionBe able to shutdown the pumping system at the first sign of any problem :
For More Information:
| Top of Page | Issue: 17-16 Application of liquid manure/organic material on tile drained landTiled land has many benefits, however, when liquid manure is applied on tiled land, extra precautions must be undertaken to ensure that manure does not move through the macropores in the soil (preferential flow) directly to tile drains. Macropores and cracks in the soil should be broken before liquid manure can move through them. Pathogens and nutrients, including ammonium nitrogen and phosphorus are the major concern for contaminating surface water. Generally, the higher the application rate, or volume being applied, the greater the risk for preferential flow to tiles. When liquid or solid manure is applied followed by rainfall event, the risk is also increased for preferential flow. Consideration should be given to postponing application or incorporating manure as quickly as possible when rain is forecast. If your land has tile drains, it is important to prevent manure nutrients from flowing through them. If manure contaminated water is entering tile drains, appropriate action should be taken to correct the problem.. What can you do?Option #1 - ActionMonitor the tile drains and take action in the event of manure flow through tile drains:
Option #2 - Action
Option #3 - ActionWhen tile outlet locations are not known prevent manure from entering tile drainage systems in the first place:
For More Information:
| Top of Page | Off-farm Sources of NutrientsIssue: 17-17 Sewage biosolids or treated septage, food processing wastes municipal or industrial compostOff-farm sources of nutrients can be used as a nutrient source for cropland. Before application, a Certificate of Approval must be obtained from the Ontario Ministry of Environment. Off-farm source materials have restrictions and/or limits for metal content, maximum application rates, time of application and separation distances that can be more restrictive than those for manure application. What can you do?Option #1 - ActionMake sure you obtain all required permits and meet all regulations and observe application setbacks:
For More Information:
| Top of Page | For more information:Toll Free: 1-877-424-1300 Local: (519) 826-4047 E-mail: ag.info.omafra@ontario.ca |
This site is maintained
by the Government of Ontario
Queen's
Printer for Ontario
Last Modified: