The Importance of Thinning Apples Chemically


This article was reviewed by the editor of Orchard Network for technical accuracy and appropriateness.

Apple producers are challenged this time of year with a number of decisions on how best to chemically thin their crop. The purpose of this article is to briefly discuss some thinning recommendations, particularly as they relate to Ontario, and to highlight the relationship between the number of fruit per tree, tree density, yield, and final fruit size.

Apples (and other tree fruits) typically produce an overabundance of flowers each year, but only 6-10% of the flowers are required to set and produce fruit. If these are all permitted to develop, too many fruit will fail to develop acceptable market size. Excess fruit is removed commercially by chemical and hand thinning, however the latter is labourious and costly. In general, the number of fruit should be reduced to approximately 5 to 7 fruits per cm of limb circumference in order to achieve adequate size. All healthy, mature, bearing trees with sufficient bloom are candidates for chemical thinning. Trees that carried a light crop last year will have a heavy bloom and will need to be thinned extensively. Furthermore, trees with a light bloom this year will set a higher percentage of fruits than those with heavy bloom, thus need to be thinned lightly.

Chemical thinning increases fruit size, return bloom, fruit colour, disease and pest control, and reduces alternate bearing, limb breakage, harvesting and handling costs, and fruit clustering. Although hand thinning is a fallback, don't rely on it exclusively. Inadequate thinning often results in depressed crop value and increased harvesting cost - much more than will be experienced by light to moderate over thinning. You should therefore consider every opportunity to thin your fruit chemically.

Chemical thinning is a difficult process, often thought to be more art than science. Regardless, it is one that orchardists must master to be successful. Poor thinning results in the loss of more crop value than all other problems combined.

To achieve successful chemical thinning, a grower is advised to keep accurate records, observe conditions in the orchard, and understand the factors, which affect the chemical thinning response. Such information can then be put together to select the best material, rate, and timing for the chemical thinning operation.

 

The relationship of fruit per tree, tree density, yield, and desired marketable fruit size

Rather than approach the subject of thinning (crop load adjustment) by relating how many fruit need to be removed from the tree, consider how many fruit should be left on a tree to obtain optimal fruit size. Growers can estimate this by estimating their yield (bins/ha) and dividing this by their tree density (trees/ha) and number of apples to fill a bin for a given minimum fruit size (Table 1). For example, if a grower has an orchard spaced at 6.5' x 13' (500 trees/acre), and an average yield of 1,000 bushels/acre, 251 fruit per tree would be required to produce a crop with an average minimum size of 3" (113 count) apples. If this calculation is reworked for a grower wishing to produce fruit with a minimum size of 2 ½", an additional 100 apples (total 362) should be left on the tree. It would be beneficial for growers to work through the exercise of estimating the maximum number of fruit required per tree to achieve the minimum size of fruit of fruit they are aiming to produce.

 

Table 1 - Tray Pack Size of Apples in Relation to Number of Apples Per Bin and Per Tree
     




Tray Size





Min Size

   

No. apples required to fill bin (1)

Number of apples required per tree
for given tree density, desired yield and fruit size

Density (trees/acre) (2)
272
500
1000
Projected Yield (bu/ac)
in
mm
400
600
500
1000
750
1500
196
57.0
3920
320
480
218
436
163
327 *
175
2⅜
60.0
3500
286
429
194
389
146
292 *
163
64.0
3260
266
400
181
362
136
272 **
150
2⅝
67.0
3000
245
368
167
333
125
250 **
138
70.0
2760
225
338
153
307
115
230 **
125
2⅞
73.0
2500
204
306
139
278
104
208 **
113
3
76.0
2260
185
277
126
251
94
188 **
100
3⅛
79.0
2000
163
245
111
222
83
167 **
88
83.0
1760
144
216
98
196
73
147 **
80
3⅜
84.5
1600
131
196
89
178
67
133 **
72
89.0
1440
118
176
80
160
60
120 **
64
3⅝
92.0
1280
105
157
71
142
53
107 **
* - Avoid
** - Remaining Rows - Target

(1) -18 bushel bin capacity

(2) - trees spaced at approximately 10' x 16' (272 trees/acre; free standing central leader), 6.5' x 13' (500 trees/acre; spindle type system) and 3.5' x 12' (1000 trees/acre; super spindle)

Thinning checklist

When it is time to chemically thin:

  • check sprayer calibration to ensure there is adequate spray coverage
  • spray the lower limbs less by shutting off one or more nozzles since fruit on lower limbs are easier to thin than those on upper ones
  • not to concentrate sprays above 2 X tree row volume
  • do not spray after frost or freezing temperatures. If you must, reduce the concentration 25 to 30 percent
  • do not mix chemical thinners with other fungicides or insecticides
  • recognize that thinning is greater for low vigor trees, light pruning, heavy bloom, poor pollination, high humidity before spraying, and cloudy, cool weather preceding or following the bloom period
  • review the section on thinning in OMAFRA's Publication 360.

Related Links

 


For more information:
Toll Free: 1-877-424-1300
Local: (519) 826-4047
E-mail: ag.info.omafra@ontario.ca
Author: Dr. John A. Cline - Assistant Professor/University of Guelph
Creation Date: 01 May 2003
Last Reviewed: 01 May 2003