In This Section

Frost Seeding Cereals Bumps Yield


Why Frost Seeding?

The number one reason you should consider frost seeding cereals is more yield! Farmer experience with frost seeding has been 15 - 25% greater yields. Some have even said that they have had up to 50% more yield! In 2003, the frost seeded spring wheat yield advantage was 4-8 bushels per acre (bu/ac).

There are many other potential benefits to frost seeding spring cereals. These include spreading out the workload, reducing heat and drought stress, and reducing the risk of diseases such as fusarium head blight.

On-Farm Trials

Cereal growers have known that the earlier you can seed spring cereals, the better the yield! Earlier seeding produces more and stronger plant tillers, which results in more heads per square foot. More and stronger heads per square foot usually means more yield. Table 1 summarizes on-farm comparisons of frost seeding versus dry soil seeding of spring wheat from farmers across Ontario.

Table 1 - On-farm Comparison of Frost vs. Dry Soil Seeding in Ontario in 2003
 Co-op /Treatment Frost Seeding
(bu/ac)
Dry Soil
(bu/ac)
ferris none 57.2 54.6
ferris 100 65.1 61.5
ferris 50 62.5 60.8
ferris 100 55.5 48.8
mck none 27.1 26.5
mck 100 40.8 33.3
jera none 42.3 23.2
jera 100 49.2 27.1
welton 73.0 62.0
Average 52.5 44.2

Research

Dr. Duane Falk and Dr. Bill Deen from the University of Guelph, frost-seeded spring wheat, barley and oat varieties in 2003. Their conclusions from the 1st year of this trial are that frost seeding worked for spring wheat, there was no real difference with barley, and the differences in yield was not consistent with oats. There was some stand reduction with frost seeding (Table 3). There was more tillering and the plants were slightly taller. Heading and maturity were earlier with the frost seeding. Protein was slightly lower with frost seeding, but still achieved the maximum 12.5% protein premium (Table 2). Dr. Falk noted that, there were more ‘windows of opportunity’ to frost seed than they expected.

| Top of Page |

Table 2 - Yield and Protein Comparison between Frost and Dry Soil Seeding
2003
Variety
Yield (bu/ac) Protein %
Frost Dry Soil Difference Frost Dry Soil Difference
Celtic 54 51 3.0 13.0 12.9 0.1
606 54 49 5.0 13.7 14.1 -0.4
Quantum 57 53 4.0 12.5 12.7 -0.2
Taho 55 53 2.0 13.3 13.7 -0.4
Average 55 52 3.5 13.1 13.3 -0.2

Dr.s Duane Falk & Bill Dean , Elora - University of Guelph

 

Table 3 Yield, Planting Date & Plant Stand Comparison between Frost and Dry Soil Seeding
Site Yield (bu/ac) Planting Date Plants/m2
Frost Dry Soil Frost Soil Temperature Dry Soil Frost Dry Soil
Eastep 52 48 1-Apr -6 30-Apr 263 334
Martin 47 42 11-Apr -2+ 30-Apr 382 374
Woodrill 66 64 17-Apr -4++ 8-May 333 424
Averages 55 51 9-Apr   2-May 327 378
Dr.s Duane Falk & Bill Dean , Elora - University of Guelph

| Top of Page |

For more information:
Toll Free: 1-877-424-1300
Local: (519) 826-4047
E-mail: ag.info.omafra@ontario.ca