Skip the Glyphosate Burndown and
You Could Lose 11% Yield in No-till Soybeans
| Author: |
Mike Cowbrough - Weed Management Field Crops Program Lead/OMAFRA;
Dr. François Tardif - University of Guelph
|
| Creation Date: |
04 May 2009
|
| Last Reviewed: |
04 May 2009
|
An 11% yield loss was observed in glyphosate tolerant soybeans when the
first glyphosate application was delayed from pre-planting until the cotyledon
to unifoliate stage in 2008 University of Guelph research trials (See
Table 1). These results demonstrate that fields with a lot of weeds emerging
before the crop will significantly reduce yield if not controlled prior
to crop emergence.
Table 1 Comparison of soybean yields at Elora and Woodstock,
Ontario from a pre-plant burndown treatment versus a delayed burndown
treatment occurring at the cotyledon to unifoliate stage.
| |
|
Soybean Yield (bu/ac)* |
| Location |
Weed Density (at Burndown) |
Burndown |
Delayed burndown |
| Elora, ON |
120 plants/m2 |
53** |
47 |
| Woodstock, ON |
20 plants/m2 |
48*** |
47 |
* An in-crop glyphosate application was made to both treatments at the
1st to 2nd trifoliate stage
**95% confidence that the application of a burndown treatment resulted
in this yield benefit
*** The application of a burndown in Woodstock did not significantly impact
soybean yield.
Residual herbicides "buy time"
Once the crop is up, it should be kept weed-free from the 1st to 3rd trifoliate
stage to minimize yield losses from weed competition. If you have fields
with heavy weed pressure, adding a residual herbicide to the pre-plant
burndown appears to mitigate the risk of yield loss that comes from delayed
in-crop glyphosate applications due to unsuitable weather conditions.
At the Elora Research Station in 2008, a 10 day delay in the in-crop application
caused a 5 bu/ac reduction in yield. This reduction in yield was eliminated
when a residual herbicide was added to the pre-plant glyphosate treatment.
Table 2 The addition of a residual herbicide to glyphosate in
a pre-plant burndown for no-till glyphosate tolerant soybeans
| |
Yield (bu/ac) at two in-crop application timings |
Burndown Treatment |
1st - 2nd trifoliate |
2nd- 3rd trifoliate (10 days later) |
| glyphosate |
53 bu/ac |
48 bu/ac |
| glyphosate + Valtera |
52 bu/ac (NS) |
53 bu/ac (S) |
| Guardian |
52 bu/ac (NS) |
53 bu/ac (S) |
| Assignment (low rate) |
52 bu/ac (NS) |
53 bu/ac (S) |
NS = Yields not significantly different then the treatment consisting
of a glyphosate burndown followed by an in-crop glyphosate application
at the 1-2 trifoliate stage.
S = Yield significantly higher then the treatment consisting of a glyphosate
burndown followed by an in-crop glyphosate application at the 2-3 trifoliate
stage.
For more information:
Toll Free: 1-877-424-1300
Local: (519) 826-4047
E-mail: ag.info.omafra@ontario.ca
|